Searching for the Best Pizza and Deep Dish in Lake County, Illinois

Sep 12, 2025

With our dealerships located right here in Waukegan, we live, work and play right here in Lake County just like you! So, if you’re looking for great local eats, we consider ourselves somewhat of an expert or two. Today on the blog, we’re sharing some of our favorite local places to grab a slice of pizza. We’re taking a tour of some fantastic pizza and Italian joints that would make your Nonna’s Nonna blush with pride.

Whether you’re looking for regional Chicago favorites like a deep dish or you’re seeking traditional, old-world style Neopolitan pies, or the super thin handcrafted bar-pie style, you’ll find something perfect to tantalize your taste buds So, hop on in to your new car from Classic and grab your pals because we’re on the quest to find the best pizzas ever! Tell us your favorites in the comment section!

(In alphabetical order, not order of preference)

Antioch Pizza Shop in Antioch

For more than 40 years, this shop has built a reputation as a fan favorite for pizza fanatics around the country. Choose from one of four pizza styles: Thin crust, the Double Decker, Pan Pizza, or Stuffed. They’ve also got a super yummy Gluten Free Pizza for those on a speciality diet. Local favorites here include the BLT Pie and the Bacon Double Cheeseburger, but their shining star is the Buffalo Chicken with its spicy buffalo sauce, deliciously moist chicken, and creamy mozzarella cheese.

Bonta Pizzeria and Restaurant in Lincolnshire

This family owned-and-operated restaurant offers bold, authentic Italian flavor in a cozy, casual atmosphere. These neapolitan pizzas pack a punch in their handmade crusts and handcrafted toppings baked off in a wood-burning brick oven. Only the finest ingredients are used! Select from traditionally made calzones or pizzas with specialties such as the Spek & Burrata, Buffalo Margherita, and Regina Pizzas or the local favorite Sausage and Mozzarella Calzone. Dinner options also include a wide array of Italian inspired appetizers like the classic Antipasto and Arancini (vegetarian options available), and a wide selection of pasta entrees.

Bricks Wood Fired Pizza in Naperville

Casual style dining with an upscale taste! This is the home of authentic wood fired and brick oven pizza since 2005, making them a relative “newcomer” in regional pizza fare, but no less of an expert at their craft. You’ll never get bored of the “same old, same old” here! Choose from unique pizza like the “Betty White Arugula” or the “Sunny Side Up” and the simply delectable “Honey Love” pie. And of course, be sure to check the rotation of their signature seasonal favorites (currently the “Red, White, Bleu” and the “Hawaiian BBQ”).

Crosstown Pub & Grill in Naperville

This is a local hub for great pub food and local sports that boats some of the best pizza and wings around. While they are far from the traditional pizza, the Crosstown Turbo Flats are really out of this world. Try the Chk Thai Thai for a pizza style flat bread with a little pizazz! Or combine their legendary wings with a flat bread pizza experience. Wash ‘em down with an ice cold brew and enjoy the Bears game while you’re there! It’s top notch, one-of-a-kind eatin’.

Lou Malnati’s in Grayslake

Locals call this pizza some of the best Deep Dish in the region with their famous Buttercrust for the most authentic Chicago option! Their famous Chicago-style pizzas offer a homemade tomato sauce with extra ooey-gooey cheese for that perfect pull with every slice. You simply must try the Malnati Chicago Classic topped with delectable sausage and extra cheese. We’re aces about this one, too, because even our gluten free pals can enjoy a classic deep dish with their small gluten-free from scratch pizzas.

Louie’s Pizza in Waukegan

This local haunt has been getting top marks since 1941, and that sense of comfort and nostalgia keeps people coming back year after year! Customers love their classic cheese pizza, but that’s not all they love. Reviewers report their taste buds are delighted by the garlic butter bread starter, as well as specials on the menu like the “Poor Mans Lobster” (cod with hot melted butter), Greek Salad, Classic Spaghetti and Meatballs, and their drink specials. It’s some of the best pizza around in the county.

Pizzeria DeVille in Libertyville

This modern pizza joint offers authentic wood fired pizzas and Italian fare along with a wicked Sunday brunch! We highly recommend trying out their signature salads while you’re there, like the classic Caprese Salad, the Maa Salad, or the unique Meatball Salad! Local favorite pizza options include the classic Margherita, Chicken & Waffle pizza, Hot Honey Square, Cup & CHar rPepperoni and Hot Honey Stuffed Motorcity, the vegan friendly Veganator Deluxe, and even a Gluten Free Pizza. You simply must try it!

Quonset Pizza in Waukegan

You’re getting old-fashioned classic thin crust pizzas, along with local favorites like Chicago-style Italian beef and of course, wings! Customers here rave about how perfect the pizza crust is, and the delicious amount of toppings you can choose from. While you can never go wrong with a traditional cheese pizza, locals also recommend asking for the “BLT Pizza” or “The Works”.

Slyce in Wauconda

Creating pizzas in the old-world style coal-fired tradition, you’ll find pizza with flavors like none other. Their specialty high-heat cooking is a clean-burning method that leaves you with a charred crust and soft, chewy interior for the ultimate pizza perfection. The ease of the Build Your Own Pizza menu allows you to fully customize all of your favorite toppings and cheeses, and they do have a gluten free crust option! In addition to more than 15 in-house signature pizzas, there’s also a full soup and salad menu as well as small plate options and sandwiches.